commentary on Politics and a little bit of everything else

After 5 Years ……Louisiana wins money to rebuild a Hospital damaged by Hurricane Katrina……

Five years!!!

With FEMA fighting to not replace a Hospital damaged by the Countries worst storm in modern history……


Cheryl Gerber for The New York Times

The waiting room of Charity Hospital in New Orléans, closed since Hurricane Katrina in 2005.

Mario Tama/Getty Images

Charity Hospital in New Orleans in May 2008. The hospital has been closed since it suffered water damage during Hurricane Katrina.


Ending one of the longest-running disputes left by Hurricane Katrina, a federal arbitration panel ruled Wednesday that Louisiana would receive $474.8 million — nearly all it had requested — to pay for the replacement of Charity Hospital in New Orleans, which has been closed since the storm.

The ruling is a significant victory for state and city officials, and gives a major boost to plans to replace Charity, a state-owned hospital for the indigent, with a new $1.2 billion academic medical center in the Mid-City neighborhood.

“This is a great week in Louisiana,” Gov. Bobby Jindal, a Republican, exulted in a statement. “First, the Saints’ victory, and now we finally get the funds we need to replace Charity Hospital.”

The plan to build a new Charity has pitted economic development advocates, who hope to transform New Orleans into a biosciences center, against neighborhood preservationists, who oppose the planned destruction of historic houses in Mid-City. The preservationists argue that Charity’s 70-year-old art deco tower downtown could be reoccupied for less money, reinvigorating the central business district in the process.

The state’s ability to afford the new center, which would be built adjacent to a Veterans Affairs hospital, had been linked to the outcome of the arbitration. An additional $300 million has been appropriated by the State Legislature, and the rest is expected to come from the sale of revenue bonds.

State officials and the Federal Emergency Management Agency had been locked in a dispute for more than four years about whether Charity was so damaged that it had to be replaced, and how much Washington would owe.

The state argued that Charity met the federal standard for replacement because damages caused by the 2005 storm amounted to more than half its value. State officials estimated the replacement cost at $491.9 million.

FEMA had projected it would cost $126.1 million to repair Charity, and had offered $150 million to settle the dispute. With the sides making little headway, Senator Mary L. Landrieu, Democrat of Louisiana, inserted language in the stimulus bill last year to create a binding arbitration process.

The arbitration panel, consisting of three judges from the Civilian Board of Contract Appeals, ruled quickly after a weeklong, closed-door hearing in Washington that ended on Jan. 15. The only victory for the emergency management agency was that the judges accepted its slightly lower estimate of the hospital’s replacement cost.

In their ruling, the judges noted that the agency’s officials “were less experienced and less credible” than the consultants hired by the state to assess damage at Charity.

While FEMA questioned whether some of the damage was storm-related, “the witnesses and record offered inadequate support to make the skepticism reasonable,” they wrote.

The panel noted that some of Charity’s systems were operating “at a sub-optimal level” before the hurricane and that the state’s protection of the building after the storm “may not have been perfect.” But it indicated that its ruling had not been a close call.

“It’s unfortunate that it took this long to get to this point, but we’re glad that we’re finally there,” said P. Raymond Lamonica, general counsel for the Louisiana State University System, which would own the newly constructed hospital.

Jack Davis, president of Smart Growth for Louisiana, which opposes the new medical center, said the arbitration ruling should spur the state to rebuild the old Charity, which he said would be faster and less expensive to construct. Among other things, Mr. Davis said, it would save the time and cost of defending lawsuits that have challenged the new site on environmental grounds.

“Sometime soon, it will dawn on the political leadership that they can’t do the big expensive L.S.U. plan,” he said, “and that they’re going to have to settle on $800 million of new hospital, using Charity.”



January 28, 2010 Posted by | Breaking News, Family, Government, Health, Healthcare, Media, PoliticalDog Calls, Politics, The Economy, Travel, Updates, Weather | , , , | 8 Comments

Merlin on Senator David Vitter in Louisiana…….

Hi Dog!

Despite some miss-steps in the past Louisiana Junior Senator David Vitter (R) looks safe for Reelection according to a new Poll.

The only Threat he had been a probable Primary Challenge from LA Secretary of State Jay Dardenne…. BUT today Dardenne announced he would not primary Vitter.

Rasmussen Survey

Louisiana Senate 2010

Senator David Vitter (R)  53 %
Rep. Charlie Melancon (D)  35 %
Others  4 %
Undecided  8 %

Secretary of State Jay Dardenne (R)  53 %
Rep. Charlie Melancon (D)  31 %
Others  6 %
Undecided  10 %


Update.…Merlin provides a link on Louisiana SoS Jay Dardenne…..

January 19, 2010 Posted by | Breaking News, Government, Media, Men, PoliticalDogs Merlin, Politics, Polls, Updates, Women | , , , , | 4 Comments

Louisiana Sen Vitter on the interracial couple in his state that got denied a marriage license….

Ah, he punted…first when asked about the issue back in end of October….Louisiana Republican Sen. David Vitter avoided the question…then in a follow up by staff…he affirms that judges should follow the law….hum???

November 22, 2009 Posted by | Government, Politics | , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Louisiana interracial couple find another justice of the peace and get married….

Beth Humphrey and Terrance McKay, the interracial couple down in Louisiana who where denied a marriage license earlier this month, are now married..in the story we posted here…the couple were first refused a marriage license by Keith Bardwell, a justice of the peace in Tangipahoa Parish’s 8th Ward……an area 70% white and 30% black…….

The State’s Governor Bobby Jindal (Indian-American) and  US Senator Mary Landreiu have deplored Bardwell’s actions, with the Governor asking that he be removed from office……which fly in the face of the US Supreme Court ruling in Loving v. Virginia which outlawed racially based limitations on marriage……

Let’s see if the guy is still doing his act a while from now……..

October 29, 2009 Posted by | Law, Media, Politics | , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

It is 2009, right?…..In Louisiana a interracial couple gets denied a marriage license……..

In a country with it’s first biracial president, this is still going on………..A couple gets denied a marriage license in Louisiana because an elected official, Keith Badwell, a justice of the peace, is worried about the children the couple might have and in his experience, most interracial marriage’s don’t last.

Oh, really?……Who appointed him to do racial selection?

And he trys to treat everyone equally.?…..yea, we see that……

Update:……Applications for marriage licenses in the Parish of Tangipahoa must be made three days before the ceremony…there is a 72 hour waiting period…….The  couple need only have a birth certificate and Social Security Card to get married. The license costs $35. The couple’s names are Beth Humphrey, 30 and Terence McKay, 32 , both live in Hammond, Louisiana……..He’s black and she’s white………and  Bardwell says…. “I didn’t tell this couple they couldn’t get married, I just told them I won’t do it”…….

October 16, 2009 Posted by | Breaking News, Law, Media, Other Things, Politics | , , | 18 Comments

Sen. David Vitter leads in Louisiana……..

Yep….Vitter,  soiled and all, has a ten point lead in the race for Senator from Louisiana………will wonders ever cease?

October 7, 2009 Posted by | Politics | , , | 2 Comments